Michael's Movie Grade: B
A raunchy but sweet feminist fable.
In this film, a single fisherwoman is treated as a joke by all the citizens of her village. With hopes of getting the villagers off her back, she asks the basket weaver to make her a husband. The weaver makes her a living man made out of wicker that is deeply in love with her. To her surprise, she falls for him as well.
Even with its raunchy sense of humor and frankness about sex, this story is first and foremost a fable in the traditional vein. This takes place in a world that immediately sets itself up as some place distinctly different from our own. Like many fairy tales, this story takes place in what is obviously the past. However, where and when this past we are seeing is not specified. Setting it apart from any specific time or place makes the fantasy easily more acceptable. When the film starts, we see a wedding that resembles our own weddings but has different traditions that don't really exist in our world. Immediately we are thrown into a world that is quite different from our own yet still holds a mirror up to our society. Because of this, the movie can make commentary on gender roles and marriage without ever sermonizing to us, the way a realistic film set in modern day might. This also allows for us to believe any fantasy concept that the story has for us without any questioning.
This movie also has a really sweet heart to it. There is something that is automatically charming about the main romance. Despite the emphasis on their sex lives, the love they feel for each other has an almost pure and innocent feel to it. This is especially true as it is contrasted with the more traditional marriages we see from the other characters (which provide a cynical representation of what a traditional marriage looks like). As the film goes on, we care more and more about this relationship. This makes some scenes quite touching and moving.
The film also benefits from an extremely strong cast. The fisherwoman is a type of role we have seen Oliva Colman play before, but she is so perfect for it that you may not care. Bill Skarsgaurd is wonderful in the role of the wicker husband, giving a real humanity to this other worldly creation. Peter Dinklage is ideally cast as the wise basket maker with his voice perfectly fitting the fable-like feel to this film.
However, as much as the story works, the raunchy humor often falls flat. Despite the amount of comedy here I only laughed a couple times. Most of the jokes are very raunchy but that does not automatically make them funny. Simply having characters talk graphically about sex and ogle the wicker man's giant penis is not funny in and of itself. Some scenes feel raunchy just to be raunchy without actually adding anything to the story or providing any laughs.
This film was directed by the team of Alex Huston Fischer and Eleanor Wilson. It is their second feature film as directors. The first was the sci-fi comedy Save Yourselves! (2020).
Though as a comedy it may fall flat, this is a very charming and intelligent fable.